| Environment & Health | ISSN: 2077-7477 eISSN: 2077-7485 |
No: 1 (114) - 2025 - Pages: 30-38
To the question of optimizing the volume of experimental studies in justification of the medical and sanitary standard for pesticides in soil
Korshun M.M.1, Gorbachevskyi R.V.1
1 Bogomolets National Medical University, Kyiv, Ukraine
ÓÄÊ: ÓÄÊ 613.63:632.95:631.4
ABSTRACT:
The aim: verification of the reliability of the methodology for optimizing the volume of experimental studies in the substantiation the medical and sanitary standard of the active substance (AS) for plant protection products (PPP) in the soil based on the analysis of the results of laboratory experiments on the study of the migration of pesticides of different chemical classes in the «soil - adjacent environments» system in extreme soil and climatic conditions. Materials and methods. According to the original methodology, the danger of contamination of the surface layer of the atmospheric air due to evaporation from the soil of 7 AS PPP, for which the maximum allowable concentrations in the soil (MPCs) were previously substantiated, was carried out. For this purpose, the risk of the possible inhalation effect of the studied AS on the body of agricultural workers and the population was assessed by determining the preliminary and final integrated hazard indexes (PIHI and FIHI, respectively). The obtained results made it possible to draw conclusions about the expediency of the experimental study of the migration of the studied AS from the soil into the air. To assess the reliability of these conclusions, the threshold concentrations of the investigated AS in the soil were analyzed according to four indicators of harmfulness, which were previously established based on the results of laboratory experiments to study the patterns of migration in the «soil - adjacent environments» system when justifying the MPCs. Results. It was established that the herbicides amicarbazone (chemical class – triazolones), bicyclopyrone (triketones), imazapyr and imazethapyr (imidazolinones) and the fungicides dimoxystrobin (strobilurins) and pydiflumetofen (pyrazole carboxamides) by the value of PIHI (3 points for each AS) and FIHI (from 7 to 11 points) do not require experimental establishment of the threshold concentration according to the air-migration indicator of harmfulness when justifying the MPCs. The organophosphorus fungicide iprobenfos according to the PIHI (5 points) was recognized as a candidate for the experimental study of migration in the «soil - atmospheric air» system; the value of FIHI (17 points) indicates the necessity of setting the threshold concentration of iprobenfos according to the air-migration harmful index. The results of experimental studies of migration in the «soil - adjacent environments» system proved the possibility and appropriateness of a scientifically based refusal to study the migration from soil to atmospheric air of amicarbazone, both imidazolinones, bicyclopyrone, dimoxystrobin and pidiflumetofen. At the same time, the necessity and obligation of experimental study of the behavior of iprobenfos in the «soil - atmospheric air» system was confirmed. Conclusions. Using the example of experimental substantiation of the medical and sanitary standard in the soil of 7 pesticides of different chemical classes, the reliability of the method of optimizing the volume of experimental studies when establishing the MPCs of AS PPP was proven by means of a scientifically justified refusal to study in the conditions of a laboratory experiment migration in the «soil - atmospheric air» system.
KEYWORDS:
herbicide, fungicide, soil, adjacent environments, migration, maximum permissible concentration
REFERENCES:
1. Hihiienichna klasyfikatsiia pestytsydiv za stupenem nebezpechnosti DSP 8.8.1.2.002-98, [Hygienic classification of pesticides by degree of danger DSP 8.8.1.2.002-98] Postanova Pershoho zastupnyka Holovnoho derzhavnoho sanitarnoho likaria Ukrainy [Order of the First Deputy Head of the State Sanitary Doctor of Ukraine] ¹ 2, 1998 Aug 28. Ukrainian
2. Honcharuk Ye, Korshun M, Salata O, Tkachenko I, Dema O. Suchasnyi stan i perspektyvy rozvytku hihiienichnoho normuvannia ekzohennykh khimichnykh rechovyn u grunti [Current status and prospects for the development of hygienic regulation of exogenous chemical substances in the soil]; In: Hihiienichna nauka ta praktyka na rubezhi stolit [Hygiene science and practice at the frontiers of the century]; 2004 May 19-21; Dnipropetrovsk.: ART-PRES;. p. 160-4. Ukrainian
3. Dopustymi dozy, kontsentratsii, kilkosti ta rivni vmistu pestytsydiv u silskohospodarskii syrovyni, kharchovykh produktakh, povitri robochoi zony, atmosfernomu povitri, vodi vodoimyshch, grunti [Permissible doses, concentrations, quantities and levels of pesticides in agricultural raw materials, food products, working area air, atmospheric air, water bodies, soil] DSanPiN 8.8.1.2.3.4-000-2001, Postanova Holovnoho derzhavnoho sanitarnoho likaria Ukrainy [Decree of the Chief State Sanitary Doctor of Ukraine] ¹ 137, 2001 Sep 20. Ukrainian
4. Pro zatverdzhennia Hihiienichnykh normatyviv i rehlamentiv bezpechnoho zastosuvannia pestytsydiv i ahrokhimikativ[For approval of sanitary and hygienic standards and regulations for the safe use of pesticides and agrochemicals], Nakaz Ministerstva okhorony zdorovia Ukrainy [Order of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine] ¹ 55, 2016 Feb 2. Ukrainian https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0207-16#Text
5. Korshun MM, Korshun OM, Martiianova YV. Risk-oriented approaches to optimize the volume of experimental studies pesticides' hygiene standard in soil (first message). Bulletin of Problems Biology and Medicine. 2023;1(2):148. https://doi.org/10.29254/2077-4214-2023-2-169-148-158
6. Korshun MM, Korshun OM, Martiianova YV. Risk-oriented approaches to optimize the volume of experimental studies pesticides' hygiene standard in soil (second message). Bulletin of Problems Biology and Medicine . 2023 ;1(3):168. https://doi.org/10.29254/2077-4214-2023-3-170-168-178
8. Honcharuk Ye. Osoblyvosti hihiienichnoho normuvannia ekzohennykh khimichnykh rechovyn u grunti[Peculiarities of hygienic regulation of exogenous chemical substances in the soil]. In: Zahalna hihiiena. Propedevtyka hihiieny[General hygiene. Hygiene education]. Kyiv: Vyshcha shkola; 1995. p. 316-24. Ukrainian
9. Pro zatverdzhennia hihiienichnykh rehlamentiv dopustymoho vmistu khimichnykh i biolohichnykh rechovyn u povitri robochoi zony[On approval of hygiene regulations for the permissible content of chemical and biological substances in the air of the working area], Nakaz Ministerstva okhorony zdorovia Ukrainy [Order of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine] ¹ 1596, 2020 Jul 14. Ukrainian https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0741-20#Text
10. Nakaz vid 07.10.2004 r. ¹ 485 "Pro zatverdzhennia Metodychnykh vkazivok «Obgruntuvannia oriientovnykh bezpechnykh rivniv vplyvu (OBRV) khimichnykh rechovyn v atmosfernomu povitri naselenykh mists» [Order dated 07.10.2004. ¹ 485 «On approval of Methodological instructions «Understanding of the orientation of safe levels of influence (OBRV) of chemical substances in the atmospheric air of populated areas»], Nakaz MOZ Ukrainy [Order of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine] ¹ 485, 2004 Oct 7. Ukrainian
11. Honcharuk Ye, Motuzynskyi M, Rokytskyi V. Kompleksne hihiienichne normuvannia ekzohennykh khimichnykh rechovyn u navkolyshnomu seredovyshchi [Comprehensive hygienic standards for exogenous chemicals in the environment]. In: Zahalna hihiiena. Propedevtyka hihiieny[General hygiene. Hygiene education]. Kyiv: Vyshcha shkola; 1995. p. 330-46. Ukrainian
12. Korshun M, Harkavyi S, Horbachevskyi R, Dema O, Korshun O. Naukove obgruntuvannia hihiienichnykh normatyviv pokhidnykh imidazolinonu u grunti [Scientific underpinnings of hygienic standards for the environmental protection of imidazolinone in soil]. In: Aktualni pytannia hihiieny ta ekolohichnoi bezpeky Ukrainy [Current issues of hygiene and environmental safety of Ukraine]; 2010 Oct 24-25; Kyiv. [place, publisher, date unknown]. p. 78-80. Ukrainian
13. Korshun M, Ruda T, Dema O, Korshun O, Horbachevskyi R, Kucherenko O. Zakonomirnosti mihratsii v systemi «grunt – sumizhni seredovyshcha» ta vplyvu na samoochyshchennia chornozemu vyluzhenoho novoho funhitsydu dymoksystrobinu [The regularities of migration in the system «soil - mixed environment» and the impact of the new fungus dymoxystrobin on the self-purification of chernozem leached]. In: Aktualni pytannia hihiieny ta ekolohichnoi bezpeky Ukrainy [Current issues of hygiene and environmental safety of Ukraine]; 2015 Oct 8-9; Ivano-Frankivsk. p. 26-8. Ukrainian
14. Korshun MM, Martiianova YV, Korshun OM. Naukove obgruntuvannia medyko-sanitarnoho normatyvu u grunti novykh stiikykh pestytsydiv – predstavnykiv riznykh khimichnykh klasiv [Scientific substantiation of the medical-sanitary regulations in the soil of modern persistent pesticides - representatives of different chemical classes]. Dovkillia ta zdorovia [Environment & Health]. 2024 Mar ;(1 (110)):57-65. Ukrainian https://doi.org/10.32402/dovkil2024.01.057
|